[Avodah] Why Not: Yehoshua BEN Nun?

[hankman]

On 15/06/2012 2:07 PM, hankman wrote:
> So just which “nevuah is decidedly new” and unknown or not revealed to 
> Moshe Rabbeinu? Is it the ma’assei merkovo (but ma sheroaso shifcha al 
> hayam ...) or the nevuas Yeshai’ahu on Gog uMogog or kibbutz Golios etc. 
> Just what would you point to as decicedly new and unknown to MR or that 
> adds new revelations unknown to MR the av hanevi’im? Don’t give me a 
> generality, but point to a specific nevuah in Nach of the type of which 
> you speak and also tell me how you know MR did not know it.

RZS responded:
Well, all of Nach. And every nevuah that didn't make it into Nach
because it had no lesson for klal yisrael. None of them were known
before they were given. So they're all new. But none of them change
the halacha.

CM responds:
I knew you would respond with this generality which is why I asked you to be 
specific and to tell us how you know that MR didn't have this revealed to 
him. So once again, please restrict your answer to one specific nevuah in 
Nach that is mechadesh Torah secrets to which MR was not privy and how you 
know that is the case.

Kol tuv
Chaim Manaster

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.aishdas.org/pipermail/avodah-aishdas.org/attachments/20120617/fbb5cc86/attachment-0002.htm>