[Avodah] Who First Said It? 6

[rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com]

RZS
> I am.  Strict construction tells me that the issur achila begins,
> midrabanan, after the 4th hour.  Absent any explicit statement
> to the contrary, that includes anything that we don't eat on Pesach.

Aderabba! The minhag is to be machmir on d'oraissos not to dafeguard
derabannans! This is loose construction NOT strict!

> there are things which we don't eat on Pesach
> itself, but do eat on Erev Pesach, the burden is on you to prove it.

taanis bechoros

And NO the burden is to prove a minhag is extended and not strictly
constructed this is obvious to any strict constructionist to read it
narrowly NOT broadly!

> Until you do, we
> must assume that when the Ramo says we don't eat matza ashira he means
> from the 5th hour of Erev Pesach until the stars come out on the 9th
> night.

Adderabba until you show otherwise why make a machloqes Rema on RT!

Any way gebrogts is a case that shlugs up the above s'vara anyway because
it's not noheig on the 8th day. And that the 8th is stricter then the
erev should be obvious! In galus it's only s'feiq erev, so there is a
s'feiq s'feiqa!


Please produce hard evidence not spin!  Show me the FIRST to say this!

AhS: O"Ch 444:5

My translation:
    Rema's kavvana is NOT that matzira ashira is not to eat matzah
    ashira Erev Pesach - rather since it's not our minhag to have it on
    Passover therefore it's not k'day to be matri'ach to make some for
    JUST shaloshudos and no more.


ZP
RRW
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile