[Avodah] Mutzkeh: Sticks, Stones, and Pets

[Doron Beckerman]

R' Micha wrote:

>> That could be true whether it is its own gezreirah or part of muqtzah.
If muqtzah is about usability on Shabbos, then letzorekh gufo o meqomo
would simply fall out of the fact that the usability is really only
because of the exclusion most common usage. It would make sense for it
to have been part of the original taqanah. <<

Mimah Nafshach. If there is indeed a Haktzaah here because of its typical
use, then normative application of Muktzeh should dictate a blanket Issur
Tiltul, and if the atypical use is sufficient to avoid a Haktzaah, then it
shouldn't be Muktzeh at all. Huktzah from certain uses making it Assur from
those particular uses, while possible, seems to be counter to what Muktzeh
is all about.

: See GRA to YD 266. This can explain, e.g., the dispute whether a
: KSHML"A can create a Bosis.
>> What would be the lemaaseh? A KSHMLI could be moved letzarich meqomo,
and a basis is meqomo. So even if it could create a basis, when would
it create an issur letalteil? <<

The L'Maase is whether one may move the Basis Mechamah L'Tzeil.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.aishdas.org/pipermail/avodah-aishdas.org/attachments/20080412/1331c1c3/attachment-0002.htm>