[Avodah] zman hadloko erev Shabbos and motzoei Shabbos

[A & C Walters]

I wrote

>>>>You are right. The Gr"o himself makes this point, that the zman daled 
>>>>mil
>>>>is only in Bavel/EY.

This means, of course, that in Chu"l anywhere north of EY, one has to be 
more machmir mot"tzsh than 72 mins, which means that if 72 mins is accepted 
as sho shovious, it comes out a kula. Those who claim that RT is only nogeia 
in Chu"l not in EY because in EY it gets dark quicker (metzius) are mistaken 
(I'm not refering to those who say it's not nogeia in EY because many pasken 
shitas haGro)

MeMonofshach. If we go sho shovious, it's zicher nogeia in EY. Even if we go 
Sho zmanious it's davka nogeia in EY (and in North America/Western Europe, 
it should be more than 72 mins. Shver on RMF who says 50 in NYC)

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Click to generate a targeted mailing lists to grow your business
http://tags.bluebottle.com/fc/KCuXzzV1W3oWUuapSs3bxTmfTkyPws/