[Mesorah] R'tzon Konam vs. Koneihem
Richard
rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com
Fri Jun 21 14:10:58 PDT 2013
FWIW
R Hofmeister has "Konam" in Birkas halvanah - p. 309 on the bottom
See Or Zarua M"Y blue eidition
Siman 457 p. 701 . Left column has "konam"
See Mss. fn 12
See explnatory fn 7 [zayin]
Konam
Girsas shas l'foneinu
Rif in B'rahco
Rosh in Sanhedrin
Tur
Some have Koneihen
Seder Rav Amram Gaon
Rambam [unlike Baer]
Shibbolei haleket
Orchos Chaim
Abudarham
Nimuek Yosef Sanhedrin.
Now see Or Zau'a same edition p. 702 "v'akoneihem ko'ei"
O"Z flips his version in the very same siman!
Fn 13 [Yud gimmel] see shinuy nusachos in fn 8 [chess]
This was what I was learning just last Shabbos that triggered my very first post on this thread.
----------------------------------------
See Siddur Eizor Eliyahu p. 34 Konam v"lo koneihem
All out siddurim have koneihem except Siddur Cracow Year 338
He quotes Baer that S'phardim have Konam. Baruch Shekivanti, that he also found nothing in S'phardic siddurim to support that girsa. That seems due to the Arizal.
See also Eizor Eliyahu P. 142 re: Birkas Halvanah that they davka picked 2 divergent versions.
-----------------------------------------
“Everyone thinks of changing the world, but no one thinks of changing himself.”
~ Leo Tolstoy
Shalom, RRW
More information about the Mesorah
mailing list