[Avodah] Minyan Choices

Rich, Joel JRich at sibson.com
Fri Oct 12 05:26:57 PDT 2018


[Micha:]
> I hope you are really what I would choose, and not what I should choose.
> Because lehalakhah, Qdushah and the greater number of Qaddeishim give
> priority to Shacharis. Not to mention there being no heter in the morning
> to compromise the mitzvah at hand for plans of a later mitzvah.

> But what I would prefer is minchah, in a heartbeat. Shacharis has all
> that lead in. By the time we get to Shema and Shemoneh Esrei, I can
> have kavanah. Minchah -- minyan allows for a greater change of context.
> Here I am coming from the workplace, the only prep is Ashrei (or an
> abbreviated Qorbanos and Ashrei). I need the minyan to have any likelihood
> of feeling

The question of relative priorities is always complex. I don't think
this question has an algorithmic response Other than if you say all
other things are equal, Which of course they never are.

Kt
Joel Rich


More information about the Avodah mailing list