[Avodah] reviit

[Eli Turkel via Avodah]

In the sefer of Rav Aviner he brings many examples of gedolim who used a
kiddush cup the size of the shiur of R Chaim Naeh (86 CC) and not CI.
He says he heard from RSZA that when RCN published his sefer on shiurim the
rabbis of Yerushalayim were astounded at his chumra !!

1) cup if Chafetz Chaim (from his grandson R Hillel Zaks)
2) cup of GRA (baal eyanim le-mishpat who got it as an inheritance)
3) cup someone got from Ohr Sameach (mesoros she-avdu)
4) Rebbe of Gur - Pnei Menachem stated about the cup of his father Baal
Imre Ha-emes
5) cup of R Salanter (Shut Teshuvot Vehanhagot)
6) Rav Dessler used a small cup that belonged to his wife's family. After
she passed away he used a larger cup
7) cup of the father of the CI
8) Brother of CI used a cup he got from his father-in-law (Cheshek Shlomo
of Vilna) and also had shiur RCN
9) R Elyashiv used a cup the size of CI but explained that he did so in
honor of CI not because that is the halacha
10) In the sefer Meged Givat Olam second volume p34) someone showed RMF a
cup holding about 88cc and RMF remarked that it was kosher lechatchila (not
not the shiur published in his name)
11) In Divrei Yoel the Satmar rebbe is quoted as saying the shiur of reviit
is 75 gram (!?)



-- 
Eli Turkel
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.aishdas.org/pipermail/avodah-aishdas.org/attachments/20150412/3a770035/attachment-0007.html>