[Avodah] hilchot Pesach
Danny Schoemann
doniels at gmail.com
Mon Apr 2 22:44:06 PDT 2012
Me, yesterday:
> He mentioned that there would be a problem with Muktza, since Bein
> haShmoshos the Chametz is forbidden.
R' Eli Turkel
> I did some more research.
> Shmirat Shabbat Kehilchato explicitly allows eating chametz on the shabbat
> immediately following Pesach based on a Rav Akiva Eger. He has an extensive
> footnote asking why it is different from ornaments after Succot. Among
> other answers he brings one from CI. Hence, this seems to be universally
> held that "Migo De-ikzai" doesnt hold from yomtov to shabbat. All this only if
> he gets a present from a Goy.
I asked R' D. A. Morgenstern shlita this morning what he really said.
He said:
There's on opinion in Tosafos that something fit for a poor person but not for a rich one is Muktza for the rich person.
However, the MB paskens that since the Chometz belonged to a Goy during Bien haShmashoth, it is not Muktza; the only issue would be stealing from the Goy.
I stand corrected.
- Danny
More information about the Avodah
mailing list