[Avodah] Mordechai and Esther

Eliyahu Grossman Eliyahu at KosherJudaism.com
Thu Mar 10 04:03:21 PST 2011


> From: Eli Turkel <eliturkel at gmail.com>
> Subject: [Avodah] Moshe Rabbenu and his family
> Just came from a shiur of R. Benny Lau and he pointed out that most of our
> impressions of Mordecai and Esther and the Jewish community come from
> midrashim.
> Basing himself strictly on the pshat and what he admitted was a minority
of
> midrashim he had a completely different take on the entire story (He just
> published a book on the topic)
>
> -- 
> Eli Turkel

What is the title of the book? I would be interested in reading it, and
could not find any reference on the Internet.

I recently attended a shuir by a local Rav who spoke of the Midrash that has
Achashveiros celebrating because of the end of the 70 year period of Jewish
exile (with a calculation error) as but one opinion, and that the entire
story takes on a different flavor if you move it before/during/after the
building of the second Temple. Many would have a problem with Mordechai, a
member of the Men of the Great Assembly and leader of the Jews of his area,
remaining a chutznik, taking a cushy job (pun intended), and lots of
benefits rather than following Ezra and Nechamiah. And so making it BEFORE
takes the sting out of it. I personally like to consider all three
possibilities, since my liking seems to vary from reading to reading!

All the best.

Eliyahu Grossman
Efrat, Israel



More information about the Avodah mailing list