[Avodah] The Meaning of Chilul Shabbos

[Yitzchok Levine]

The following is from RSRH's commentary on Shemos 31

14 Therefore keep the Sabbath, for it is a sacred 
thing for you. Those who desecrate it shall be 
put to death, for whoever performs [creating] 
work on it, that soul will be uprooted from the midst of its society.

Chilul Shabbos literally means “the killing of Sabbath” — i.e., destroying
the living and life-giving ideal of the Sabbath. Essentially, this can only
be done in the presence of others; for whoever violates the sanctity of
the Sabbath in the presence of others diminishes their inner experience
of its sanctity or even deprives them of this experience altogether.

Our verse, then, speaks of the desecration of Sabbath in the presence
of witnesses, who are always representatives of the community. Whoever
desecrates the Sabbath in the presence of witnesses kills before the eyes
of the nation the institution that is the foundation of the whole nation
and the foundation of its calling and mission. It is the nation’s duty to
put an end to the Sabbath-desecrator’s existence and thereby restore
the sanctity of the institution in its midst.

Keeping alive the ideal of Sabbath in the minds of the people is
such an essential part of the purposes of the institution of Sabbath (and
killing this ideal is so damaging) that — as is the case in no other law
except the understandably related one of Chilul HaShem — the concept of
farhesiya has a decisive influence on the laws of 
Chilul Shabbos. Hence, one who
desecrates the Sabbath b'farhesiya — i.e., in the presence of the national
community, i.e., ten adult members of the nation — is equated with
an oved avodah zara and is considered a mumar l'chol haTorah kula, one who has
broken with Judaism entirely (see Chullin 5a). 
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.aishdas.org/pipermail/avodah-aishdas.org/attachments/20100307/96956621/attachment-0001.htm>