[Avodah] Seeing G'zeiros Everywhere

[rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com]

Given: someone claims g'zeira means coercion

1 SA Ch M 2:1 "..Danin bein Missa, bain mammom bein kol dinei onesh..."

A Is G'zeira - as a form of coercion - a greater or lesser coercion than
  the list above?"
B If less would it be muttar for a BD to impose it by kal vachomer? 
C If not - why not?

2 Can someone explain to me SA Ch. M. 11:1 the Remaks use of the term
g'zeira?
In particular the phrase "..g'zeiras BD o hacham.."

[Email #2. -mi]

> With regard to speaking to a person wearing hearing aids, three possible
> prohibitions should be considered:
> 1. Molid 
> 2. Hashma'at kol 
> 3. Gezeira Shema yetakein
... 
> C. Gezeira shema yetakein (Lest one make repairs) The Shulchan Aruch
> rules that on Shabbat "it is forbidden to produce sound with a musical
> insturment."47 the reason given is that it may lead to the repair of
> musical instruments, in violation of the biblical prohibition against
> completing the construction of an object.48

> Although the Talmud seems to limit this prohibition to the production of
> a "sound of song," the wording of Shulchan Aruch clearly indicates that
> in his opinion this prohibition includes the production of any sound on
> a musical insturment.49

> Ramo takes it a step further and prohibits the production of sound on
> any instrument designed for that very purpose (such as a doorknocker)
> even if it is not used to play music. As a result, numerous authorities
> prohibit speaking into a microphone on Shabbat since sound is being
> produced on an instrument whose function is to produce sound (and is
> often used to accompany sounds of song).50 since a hearing aid and
> microphone are identical in terms of their operation,51 it must be
> determined whether there is any distinction52 between them with regard
> to this gezeira shema yetakein.53

> Some authorities suggest that the proscription of the Sages was never
> intended to include an item such as hearing aids for the following
> two reasons:...

The Use of Hearing Aids on Shabbat \ Rabbi Elysha Sandler
http://www.daat.ac.il/DAAT/english/Journal/sandler-1.htm 

KT 
RRW 
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile