[Avodah] shatz saying things aloud

[rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com]

"Rav 
believed that the congregation should hear every word of the hatzarat 
ha-shatz... including the Modim Anachnu.  This suggests that the Shaliach 
Tzibbur should also say Modim Anachnu aloud, rather than the common 
practice of saying it in a mumble while the tzibbur says the Modim 
d'Rabbanan".


As a shat afaik modim should be said aloud;

BUT I usually do so @ a reduced v olume whilst cong. Is doing modim derabbana.n.  Tri koli lo mishtam'ei...

However, if the shul waits for. Cong. To finish then I do full voice.

Fwiw MB requires no such wait

Fwiw 2 when I needed to drag out davening  on YK I used modim outloud to do so,
 
Kt
Rrw
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile