[Avodah] shatz saying things out loud

[rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com]

"BTW as a historical anamoly one of the things a chazzan should say
privately is the
prayer of "hineni harash" befor ethe shemone esre on RH/YK. This is
his private prayer
that everything come out okay. Instead it has become one of the piyyutim where
chazzanim show off their voice."

Fwiw yekkes STILL do "hinneni heakoni mima'as"  privatley for both shacharis and musaf of rh and all 5 tefillos on yk.

Aiui yekkes are more rigid and less prone to innovation.  In this case - as with many others - preserv ing the OLD minhag is the better way to go aisi.

KT
RRW


Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile