[Avodah] Skipping Korbanos

Moshe Y. Gluck mgluck at gmail.com
Wed Apr 2 23:28:41 PDT 2008


R' MB:
> No. But neither are they. They are bowing out of chazaras hasha"tz in
> a world where it takes a R' Chaim Brisker to explain why it's necessary
> despite the publication of the siddur. (Tzvei dinim: tefillah BEtzibur
> and tefillas HAtzibbur.)
> 
> Much lower-level involvement in Torah versus a much sligher chiyuv
> (takanah that outlived its purpose vs deOraisa). Same reasonining,
> different plane.
> 
> : Secondly don't Chazal say "Zman Torah lechud uzman tefilla lechud"?
<SNIP>
> Once you finish NhC cheileq 4, you learn that Talmud Torah keneged kulam,
> and that tefillah (mitzvos in generally, really) exists only to add to
> one's TT! Maaseh, in the physical plane, is lower than speech, and
> speech is lower than machashavah. And thus everything exists to elevate
> machashavah, IOW, to serve TT.

I just bumped into a germane Yaavetz (in the Siddur, Arvis Motza'ei
Shabbos): "The custom is to sweetly drag out the tune of V'hu Rachum - even
if it is definitely evening - so as to escort the Queen and to send her away
with joy and song. For the same reason, some start the singing with
Lamenatzei'ach B'nginos Mizmor Shir. In the Ashkenazic congregations they
also add L'dovid Boruch Hashem (Tehillim 144 - MYG), and the Sefardim add
the "Eightfold" (Tehillim 119 - MYG); each according to its custom. Anyone
who adds in the praises of Hashem Yisbarach is praised, but these are not
obligatory (which is why the Arizal didn't bother to recite them. He was
certainly busy with Torah, and did not want to neglect his learning)."

KT,
MYG 




More information about the Avodah mailing list