[Avodah] halachik status of siddur

[Eli Turkel]

However, I believe that taaniot were indeed instituted for both the
crusades and Cheminilsky but were forgotten over time

chag kasher vesameach

On 4/2/07, Meir Shinnar <chidekel at gmail.com> wrote:

> I would add that the brisker psak is not based merely on the kinah -
> but on the fact that a day was not added for gzerot tatnav - and the
> kinah gives an explicit reason for what seems implicit in other
> sources - and is therefore the proof text.
> Meir Shinnar

Eli Turkel