[Avodah] What is the source for the minhag of Chasidim to etc. ....

D&E-H Bannett dbnet at zahav.net.il
Wed Nov 8 12:52:59 PST 2006


Re: magdil/migdol: To those who do not want to get into the 
TT vs. Abudarham problem, I suggest an alternative 
explanation for the change in nussach.

1.  In T. Bavli, Shabbat 115,  Rashi explains that while one 
reads nevi'im on Shabbat one does not read ketuvim on 
Shabbat.

2.  Magdil yeshu'ot is in Tehilim.  Tehilim is in ketuvim. 
One does not read ketuvim on Shabbat.

3.  Migdol yeshu'ot is in Shmuel B'. Shmuel B' is in 
nevi'im. One does read nevi'im on Shabbat.

4.  QED.


k"t,

David 




More information about the Avodah mailing list