[Avodah] (Neviim & Possible Mistakes); Akeidah & Yizchak

[hankman]

RYZ wrote:
Since the Rambam's statement of "Viyeida Ma Hu" would contradict this.

IMHO the whole Kashe has no place since this Possuk was a Chelek of the
Nvuoh itself, IOW HKB"H wanted that Daniel should not understand and ask and
be answered, which is vital in the Nkudah that it is Sosum.

CM responds:
I think we agree, so I am not sure why you claim that "the Rambam's statement of "Viyeida Ma Hu" would contradict this."? You give the likely reason as to why Daniel got all of the intended message. I guess I am adding the nekuda that possibly the mechanism for "Viyeida Ma Hu" - that the novi get not more and not less than the intended message - could well be the "aspaklaria sh'eina meira." I think we basically agree, but I see no stira from the Rambam, in fact I previously quoted exactly this line to prove my point!

RYZ further wrote:
"as such it must be completely true"

CM comments:
This again is no problem. The Novi repeats what he saw in the vision, to the extent it was revealed to him. This is the "complete truth" as far as this nevuah is concerned.

Finally, RYZ wrote:
see Hakdomas HaRambam to Perek Chelek where he explains the 4 differences
between the Nvuoh of Moshe RO"H and other nvi'im, without mentioning such an
obvious difference

CM comments:
I am not sure what additional difference you mean? The clarity of the vision is part of the difference of "aspaklaria hameira."

Kol Tuv

Chaim Manaster
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.aishdas.org/pipermail/avodah-aishdas.org/attachments/20090604/5f817308/attachment-0001.htm>