[Avodah] shiurim

Zev Sero zev at sero.name
Sun Nov 23 09:00:20 PST 2008


Eli Turkel wrote:
>>From the sefer of Beinish on Midot and Shiurim of the Torah  p74(my translation)
> 
> "Everything I wrote is only to be machmir but in places that the shiur of
> our rabbis the achronim (i.e. Nodah BeYehudah and others) results in a
> Kulah in a Torah halacha then it is proper for those fearful of paskening
> (mi-yireh horaah) to be machmir"
> 
> This is an addition to the second edition (mahadura batra) of the kuntress
> le-shiurim by the CI and does not appear in the first edition
> 
> The Steipler in his sefer Shiurei haMitzvot which he wrote according to
> the psak of CIalso writes that the shiur of an egg being 45-50 grams
> is a chumra and similarly for the size of the agudal

Yes, the "chacham echad" referred to in the footnote I quoted earlier
was probably the Steipler.  But his claims are contradicted by the CI's
own letter.

-- 
Zev Sero               Something has gone seriously awry with this Court's
zev at sero.name          interpretation of the Constitution.
                       	                          - Clarence Thomas



More information about the Avodah mailing list