[Avodah] Fwd: Re: Korbanos on Succos

[Micha Berger]

Another post from a lurker. In his first post to me, he wrote: 
> See Nechemiah 8:16, referenced in Halichos Shlomo 7:27. 

Below is his follow-up message. 

-micha

Ah, I found it - in the first volume [of Moadim uZemanim]. Succah
Simman 88 in a footnote, he says he was Mefalpel that year on how
the Kohanim ate Menachos in the Azarah, as one may not add a structure
to the Azarah based on Hakol Bichsav.

He writes: a) A Binyan Arai is allowed, just as in the Hava Amina in
Sotah 41 they built a Bimah of wood in the Azarah and there was no
objection of adding such temporary structures to the Azarah. (And
the Passuk in Nechemiah refers to the Azarah as well).

b) Shu"t Beis Yitzchak by R' Yitzchak Shmelkes says that Achilas
Kodshim Avodah and does not need a Succah (Rav Sternbuch asks on this
from the Chullin eaten along with it).

c) The same Shu't adds that they built a Succah in a room that was
built B'Chol and Pesuchah Lakodesh. (Rav Sternbuch asks on this too
from Tosefta Maaser Sheni that such a structure is a violation of Hakol
Bichsav)

d) R' Sternbuch says that on the Har Habayis where one could eat and
live, one would be obligated to build a Succah, but in the Azarah there
is no obligation to build a Succah since it cannot possibly serve as a
Beis Dirah all year round, since one is limited to Achilas Kodshim there.
So since these Kodshim could not be and were not eaten in a place which
could function as a  Beis Dirah all year round, they could be eaten
normally on Succos as well - and they need not be eaten in the temporary
Beis Dirah of the Succah.