[Avodah] pregnant women fasting on YK

Ben Waxman ben1456 at smile.net.il
Thu Jan 3 03:06:35 PST 2008


>  Rav Eli Turkel wrote:
>
>R. Nebenzahl is very mekil basically on the grounds given by
>Meir Sheinar. Others (i have heard it from R. Zilberstein) are machmir
>on the grounds that pregnant women have fasted on YK for many years
>and we have no record in shutim of any problems.

1) I read that Rav Yaacov Fisher gave a blanket heter for women in 
their 3rd trimester not to fast.
2) Your second point, that there is no record in shutim, I find very 
strange. Does a posek have to wait until the problem makes its way to 
a shut before reopening the question?

KT

Ben 




More information about the Avodah mailing list