<html>
<head>
<meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=windows-1255">
<meta name="Generator" content="Microsoft Exchange Server">
<!-- converted from rtf -->
<style><!-- .EmailQuote { margin-left: 1pt; padding-left: 4pt; border-left: #800000 2px solid; } --></style>
</head>
<body>
<font face="Helvetica" size="2"><span style="font-size:10.5pt;">
<div style="margin-bottom:12pt;"><font color="#444444">I’m hoping somebody can help me out with this. We’re looking into the question of eating fish and meat together. The Tur in o”c states that his father, the Rosh, would wash between eating meat and fish.</font></div>
<div style="margin-bottom:12pt;"><font face="Helvetica (Hebrew)" color="#444444">טור<font face="Helvetica"> </font>אורח<font face="Helvetica"> </font>חיים<font face="Helvetica"> </font>הלכות<font face="Helvetica"> </font>בציעת<font face="Helvetica"> </font>הפת<font face="Helvetica">,
</font>סעודה<font face="Helvetica">, </font>וברכת<font face="Helvetica"> </font>המזון<font face="Helvetica"> </font>סימן<font face="Helvetica"> </font>קעג<br>
וא<font face="Helvetica">"</font>א<font face="Helvetica"> </font>הרא<font face="Helvetica">"</font>ש<font face="Helvetica"> </font>ז<font face="Helvetica">"</font>ל<font face="Helvetica"> </font>היה<font face="Helvetica"> </font>רגיל<font face="Helvetica">
</font>ליטול<font face="Helvetica"> </font>ידיו<font face="Helvetica"> </font>בין<font face="Helvetica"> </font>בשר<font face="Helvetica"> </font>לדגים</font></div>
<div style="margin-bottom:12pt;"><font color="#444444">In y”d he states that one should not eat meat and fish together.</font></div>
<div style="margin-bottom:12pt;"><font face="Helvetica (Hebrew)" color="#444444">טור<font face="Helvetica"> </font>יורה<font face="Helvetica"> </font>דעה<font face="Helvetica"> </font>הלכות<font face="Helvetica"> </font>מאכלי<font face="Helvetica"> </font>עובדי<font face="Helvetica">
</font>כוכבים<font face="Helvetica"> </font>סימן<font face="Helvetica"> </font>קטז<br>
וצריך<font face="Helvetica"> </font>ליזהר<font face="Helvetica"> </font>שלא<font face="Helvetica"> </font>לאכול<font face="Helvetica"> </font>בשר<font face="Helvetica"> </font>ודג<font face="Helvetica"> </font>ביחד<font face="Helvetica"> </font>שקשה<font face="Helvetica">
</font>לצרעת</font></div>
<div style="margin-bottom:12pt;"><font color="#444444">The source of both statements (please disagree if you think differently) seems to be the Talmud in Pesachim quoted by the beit Yosef</font></div>
<div style="margin-bottom:12pt;"><font face="Helvetica (Hebrew)" color="#444444">בית<font face="Helvetica"> </font>יוסף<font face="Helvetica"> </font>אורח<font face="Helvetica"> </font>חיים<font face="Helvetica"> </font>סימן<font face="Helvetica"> </font>קעג<br>
ב<font face="Helvetica"> </font>ומ<font face="Helvetica">"</font>ש<font face="Helvetica"> </font>רבינו<font face="Helvetica"> </font>ואדוני<font face="Helvetica"> </font>אבי<font face="Helvetica"> </font>ז<font face="Helvetica">"</font>ל<font face="Helvetica">
</font>היה<font face="Helvetica"> </font>רגיל<font face="Helvetica"> </font>ליטול<font face="Helvetica"> </font>ידיו<font face="Helvetica"> </font>בין<font face="Helvetica"> </font>בשר<font face="Helvetica"> </font>לדגים<font face="Helvetica"> </font>דחמירא<font face="Helvetica">
</font>סכנתא<font face="Helvetica"> </font>מאיסורא<font face="Helvetica">. </font>הכל<font face="Helvetica"> </font>בו<font face="Helvetica"> (</font>סי<font face="Helvetica">' </font>כג<font face="Helvetica"> </font>טז<font face="Helvetica">.) </font>כתב<font face="Helvetica">
</font>שגם<font face="Helvetica"> </font>הר<font face="Helvetica">"</font>ם<font face="Helvetica"> </font>נ<font face="Helvetica">"</font>ע<font face="Helvetica"> </font>היה<font face="Helvetica"> </font>נוהג<font face="Helvetica"> </font>כן<font face="Helvetica">
</font>מזה<font face="Helvetica"> </font>הטעם<font face="Helvetica"> </font>ולא<font face="Helvetica"> </font>פירש<font face="Helvetica"> </font>מהיכן<font face="Helvetica"> </font>למד<font face="Helvetica"> </font>הר<font face="Helvetica">"</font>ם<font face="Helvetica">
</font>כן<font face="Helvetica"> </font>ונראה<font face="Helvetica"> </font>שלמדו<font face="Helvetica"> </font>כן<font face="Helvetica"> </font>מדגרסינן<font face="Helvetica"> </font>בפרק<font face="Helvetica"> </font>כיצד<font face="Helvetica"> </font>צולין<font face="Helvetica">
(</font>פסחים<font face="Helvetica"> </font>עו<font face="Helvetica">:) </font>ההיא<font face="Helvetica"> </font>ביניתא<font face="Helvetica"> </font>דאיטויא<font face="Helvetica"> </font>בהדי<font face="Helvetica"> </font>בישרא<font face="Helvetica"> </font>אסרה<font face="Helvetica">
</font>רבא<font face="Helvetica"> </font>מפרזקיא<font face="Helvetica"> </font>למיכלה<font face="Helvetica"> </font>בכותחא<font face="Helvetica"> </font>מר<font face="Helvetica"> </font>בר<font face="Helvetica"> </font>רב<font face="Helvetica"> </font>אשי<font face="Helvetica">
</font>אמר<font face="Helvetica"> </font>אפילו<font face="Helvetica"> </font>במילחא<font face="Helvetica"> </font>נמי<font face="Helvetica"> </font>אסורה<font face="Helvetica"> </font>משום<font face="Helvetica"> </font>דקשה<font face="Helvetica"> </font>לריחא<font face="Helvetica">
</font>ולדבר<font face="Helvetica"> </font>אחר<font face="Helvetica">. </font>ופירש<font face="Helvetica"> </font>רש<font face="Helvetica">"</font>י<font face="Helvetica"> </font>דאיטויא<font face="Helvetica"> </font>בהדי<font face="Helvetica"> </font>בשרא<font face="Helvetica">.
</font>בתנור<font face="Helvetica"> </font>אחד<font face="Helvetica">: </font>לדבר<font face="Helvetica"> </font>אחר<font face="Helvetica">. </font>צרעת<font face="Helvetica">:</font></font></div>
<div style="margin-bottom:12pt;"><font color="#444444">The gemara only talks about cooking them together in the same oven. Since this is an issue of danger, any understanding of how the prohibition got extended so far and did anybody else but the Rosh do it?
(the kolbo refers to <font face="Helvetica (Hebrew)">הר</font>"<font face="Helvetica (Hebrew)">ם</font>-who is that? (the Rambam doesn’t mention it)</font></div>
<div><font face="Arial" size="2"><span style="font-size:9.5pt;"><img width="83" height="41" src="rtfimage://"></span></font></div>
<div><font face="Times New Roman" size="3"><span style="font-size:12pt;"> </span></font></div>
</span></font>
<br><pre><font color="blue">
THIS MESSAGE IS INTENDED ONLY FOR THE USE OF THE
ADDRESSEE. IT MAY CONTAIN PRIVILEGED OR CONFIDENTIAL
INFORMATION THAT IS EXEMPT FROM DISCLOSURE. Dissemination,
distribution or copying of this message by anyone other than the addressee is
strictly prohibited. If you received this message in error, please notify us
immediately by replying: "Received in error" and delete the message.
Thank you.
</font></pre><br>
</body>
</html>