[Avodah] Support for Maaseh Satan

[Micha Berger via Avodah]

In some, more Zionist, circles, the Satmar Rebbe's position that Israel
is a maaseh satan is often left not understood. Many of the RZ camp have
summarily dismissed it as overly polytheist for their liking.

However, it is possible -- even if I or you do not find it plausible --
that Zionism was a challenge to the Jewish People. To see if after the
Holocaust we would be so desperate for political relief that we would
stop working toward true ge'ulah. As per the title of the SR's response
to the mood after the Six Day War -- Al haGe'ulah ve'Al haTemurah (About
the Ge'uilah and about the Replacement; perhaps "Decoy").

And, there is a particular mal'akh charged with posing spiritual challenges
for us to grow through overcoming -- the satan. Thus, such a temurah
would be a maaseh satan.

Pretty conventional metaphysics, even for those who find the other
religious positions bothersome.

I mentioned this because of R' Gidon Rothstein's latest column
in TM on the Ramban.
"Ramban to Re'eh, Week Two: Avoiding False Prophets, Hearing From Hashem"
http://www.torahmusings.com/2017/06/avoiding-false-prophets-hearing-hashem

Along the way, RGR writes:

   It Might Actually Be From Hashem

   In the last verse in this passage, Moshe warns that this false prophet
   is a nisayon, a test, from Hashem. Ramban points out that back
   inBereshit, he had already dealt with the question of why Hashem
   "tests" us (doesn't Hashem know the future, and therefore know the
   outcome of the test? There are many answers, this is Ramban's). It's
   only a test from our perspective, he said. Hashem indeed knows the
   outcome, and is engaging in it to bring our potential into actuality
   (that implies that everyone always passes these tests, which works
   well for figures like Avraham, Yitzchak, and Ya'akov. It seems to me
   less convincing about the nisayon here, since the Jewish people have
   in fact occasionally followed such false prophets).

   Still, that's the less surprising part of this Ramban, since it is the
   face value of the verse, that the wonder did in fact come through the
   Will of Hashem, Hashem showed him this dream or vision to test our love
   of Hashem.

   Ramban doesn't say more, but I think he means--and this is the part
   that is more surprising and a bit challenging- that all people involved
   must realize that this is not what Hashem wants. I think he means the
   prophet him/herself was supposed to refrain from giving this prophecy
   (the other option is that Hashem was commanding and condemning this
   person to be a false prophet, to forfeit his/her life in doing so, and
   that someone we would put to death as a false prophet is actually a
   hero of Hashem's service. I find that unthinkable, unless the prophet
   said "I had this vision, but you clearly shouldn't listen to because
   we're not allowed to ever worship any power other than Hashem." But
   it's logically possible).

   The prophet aside, anyone who hears that prophecy, even if it's
   supported by uncannily accurate predictions, must both refuse to obey
   and react to this person as a false prophet. That is what true ahavat
   Hashem would lead us to do, a reminder that acting on our love of
   Hashem sometimes means doing that which under other circumstances
   should be distasteful. Putting someone to death for sharing his/her
   vision is not usually conduct we applaud. Here, it would still be
   upsetting, but necessary for those whose love of Hashem fills their
   beings.

If the Ramban could say that there could be a navi sheqer who gets his
message from Hashem for the sould purpose of challenging us, is it such
a far stretch to the SR's anti-Zionism?

IMHO, it's easier to understand Satmar or Munkacz anti-Zionism than
Agudah's classical position of non-Zionism. The former agrees with the RZ
that the Medinah is a huge event of vast import, but disagree about what
the import is. The Agudist (at least classically, there were exceptions
in the early years of the state, and things seem to be wearing down now)
believe that Jews can regain sovereignty over EY for the first time in
2 millenia without it being religiously significant.

(I am not talking about those of Neturei Karta who protest with the
Palestinians and their supporters, or who visit Iranian gov't officials.
They pose a whole different and perhaps even more fundamental set of
problems. The SR's anti-Zionism included praying for Tzahal, as these
were Jews led to danger through a horrible (in his opinion) error; an
error that exists in part for the purpose of putting Jews in danger.)

Tir'u baTov!
-Micha

Cc: RGR

-- 
Micha Berger             Good decisions come from experience;
micha at aishdas.org        Experience comes from bad decisions.
http://www.aishdas.org                - Djoha, from a Sepharadi fable
Fax: (270) 514-1507