[Avodah] treif anatomy

[Eli Turkel]

<< : To the best of my knowledge this is a chiddush of CI and no one had
: mentioned this idea before.
: As such I am not sure that it is universally accepted.

The IM does. >>

Sorry, I was not clear - I meant the idea that after year 4000 things are
fixed forever is a chiddush of the CI.
I am not aware that RMF anywhere has anything similar. The specific halacha
for treif anatomy many people agree with. Rambam already implies that
trefot is different from other halachot. Rashba states that even if we have
witnesses that testify that an animal that was a terefah kived more than 12
months we dont beleive them (I really dont understand this). Most again
explain the Rshba as distinguishing terefot from other halachot.

Among other things I dont understand is that there is a machloket in the
gemara whether a terefa can kive more than 12 months
1) is this a machloket in facts?
2) does paskening that a terefah cant kive for more than 12 months alter
the physical facts to the extent that Rashba considers 2 witnesses as liars
based on this psak?

-- 
Eli Turkel
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.aishdas.org/pipermail/avodah-aishdas.org/attachments/20120712/fae33d5c/attachment-0002.htm>