[Avodah] correction to daily halacha

[mendel zirkind]

> A few corrections:
> 1. The disagreement between the Chachamim and Rabbi Yehuda is only about
> when is the (earliest) time to daven marriv and not when to say Shma.
*you are correct in psht in the mishnah however when writing for halacha
purposes shma is included in  עי' שוע"ר סי' תפט: י"*ב ו*תוס' ברכות ב*.
> 2. According to the Alter Rebbe's Siddur the period from מנחה קטנה  until
> sunset (not צאת ) is divided in half which is called  פלג המנחה
*i know and i lchatchila wrote it that way, however again im trying to keep
it simple to give a basic explanation. in truth its a machlokes *
> 3. e.g. during the time of the year when the day light is 12 hours from 6
> a.m. to 6 p.m. with the afternoon stating at 12p.m. so פלג המנחה would be
> 4:45 p.m. (not 4:30).
*correct*
> 4. The halacha says that you could choose either opinion for Maariv and if
> one davened marriv earlier he would have to say שמע again at  [3]צאת
הכוכבים
ז*ה לאו דוקא דאע"פ שכן הוא לשון המחבר סי' רל"ג מ"מ עי' במג"א סי' רס"ז:א
והמשנ"ב סי' רל"ג:יא וסי' רל"ה :יב ושער ציון שם סק"ט והטעם שמקדימים היא
לצורך מנין או בער"ש משום להוסיף מחול *....
> .
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.aishdas.org/pipermail/avodah-aishdas.org/attachments/20120430/cd86e627/attachment.htm>