[Avodah] sun and moon

Lampel zvilampel at gmail.com
Sun Aug 28 08:08:25 PDT 2011


>  The Rambam doesn't actually say the moon has an intellect.
> RZS: Yes, he does.  Explicitly.*All*  the stars*and*  spheres are intelligent,
> and they're all more intelligent than humans.

RZSero is correct: Hilchos Y'sodei HaTorah 3:9:

"All the stars and the spheres are baalei nefesh v'deah v'haskel, and 
they are living beings, and stand and recognize Mi Sheh-amar V'haya 
HaOlom. Each one,  in accordance with its greatness and level, laud and 
praise the One Who formed them, just as the angels do...and the daas of 
the kochavim and the galgalim is less than the daas of the melachim, but 
greater than the daas of bnei adam."

It should be noted that although the Rambam found scriptural support for 
this from "The heavens proclaim the Almi-ty's glory," Rav Saadia Gaon 
before him dismissed such a literal understanding of this verse (Emumos 
V'Dei'os 2:10).

Zvi Lampel



More information about the Avodah mailing list