[Avodah] dina demalchuta

David Riceman driceman at optimum.net
Thu Jul 21 12:52:41 PDT 2011


RAF:

<<Another one is the idea of halakhic neemanut.>>

I wonder if you could explain this more precisely.  It seems to me that 
the term is used for a more flexible concept than you imply here.  See 
Igros Moshe YD (1) #54 (pp. 93-94), especially his comments about the 
story in Kesubos about bas R Hisda.

<<The former position would rest on ascribing hefqer beit din hefqer 
power to the melekh.>>

Could this be the machlokes between the two psukim cited in Gittin 36b? 
Ezra got his authority from the king but Yehoshua didn't.

David Riceman




More information about the Avodah mailing list