[Avodah] Selling whiskey/bourbon

[rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com]

Akiva Miller kennethgmiller at juno.com:
> There's a whole hour during which we are machmir on eating but meikil
> on owning. (Not only does this disprove what RRW seems to be saying,
> but it is particularly surprising if both eating and owning are "mere"
> lavin from chatzos until evening.)


First
I had originally understood the passuq "so sochal alv hameitz" NOT like
the rambam - rather that one may not OWN Hameitz after the zman starts
for Qorban Pesach. Now I cannot recall where I got this idea from, so -
at least until I find a source - I simply will not pursue this line of
thinking re: erev Pesach.


Second:
As noted baal hamaor DOES allow eating to be m'qayeim tashbeesu so it's
no slam dunk.

CGS noted this is ONLY aliba d'r. Shimon and we pasqen aliba d'r. Yehudah
instead

I have alredy noted that we do NOT pasqen according to the baal hamaor
anyway.

So how does RAM understand this baal hamaor?

At any rate, I' withdraw and recant that aspect of my post because it
does not work well at all unless I can muster some sources to support it

OTOH I do reject the notion that we equate the issur hametz on EP as =
to P itself. This is contrary to everthing I have learned

EG bateil b'60 does work on EP, and mashehu starts only on P - except
Rambam might hold that both are davar sheyeish lo matirin. Even here
Rambam is m'haleig on Passover that it applies to BOTH b'mno and
sh'eino mini. I have zero evidence he holds that aspect on EP

ZP
RRW
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile