[Avodah] popcorn

[rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com]

RZS
> He doesn't have to say that.  How can the kitniyos themselves, which
> were assur, suddenly become mutar just by falling into a tavshil?»

Simple it was never "assur". If gebructhts were assur the 8th day would
not alllow for a kula either!

Rather, it's a g'zeira based upon a cheshash and the Rema is stating
that we are not gozeir on a taaroves.

Unless we have evidence somewhere that the Rema says MUST fish it out it's
not the straight read of the Rema here and there is no doubt that there is
no reason to be mahmir on the Minhag - which is the Rema's salient point.

Unlike issur mamash there is no reason to be m'haleiq. And if the Rema
meant to be m'chaleiq he would have said so.

Since he is introducing the prcinciple that the g'zeira is inapplicabe,
why fish for Humra?

Or as the Hoq Yaakov states: why be machmir on a humra!?

Zissen Pesach
RRW
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile