[Avodah] ROY and dishwashers.

[rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com]

> Rabbi Wolpoe,
> With all due respect, I believe you have read the pesak
> incorrectly. Keilim are mutter, not the process? If that was his position,
> surely he would have said it differently
> I think it best to post it and see what others say.So here it is.
> Martin Brody»

[I posted a second copy at
http://www.aishdas.org/avodah/faxes/yabiaOmerYD10:4.pdf>
-micha]

WADR it appears that Martin is confusing the SA with ROY [maybe the same
via gilgul? ;-)]

I was explaining the SA You seem to be confusing SA with ROY.
due to being anxious to prove a point w/o the benefit of even cursory
research. With such conflation I'm not sure you have a handle on SA,
ROY or my points.

I would opine that An agenda driven read is rarely an objective honest
read.

Before I post a tranlsation of SA 
I recommend to:
1 Read it slowly 3-10 times as Hacham Isaac Sasoon says "let the text
speak for itself"
2 Skip Rema and any commentaries
3 And to inform one's read. See only the SA himself EG O"Ch 452:2
And no one else
4 add commenataries later


I also recommend writing down the translation on paper and going over
with a havrusa.

Ask yourself where in the Halachic universe is using "taam pagum"
a l'chathcila heter to mix things together - viz. BbCh or issur?

I have some sources on this issue but I will be COY re: ROY and not
share them yet. ;-)

KT
RRW
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile