[Avodah] The Dynamic of Post-Talmudic Brachos

[Zev Sero]

rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com wrote:

>>> Tangentially  IIRC Rosh opposes ban on Qitniyyos.

>> Nope.  You may be thinking of the infamous maskilic forgery _Shu"t
>> Besamim Rosh_.

> Maybe so but also see Tur O"Ch 453 who calls issur qitniyyos betavshil
> as a "humra y'seira" Maybe he got that idea  from his father the Rosh

Maybe so, but it would be pure speculation.


> Note the Humra of qitniyyos as a flour is different because of "assi
> l'achalufei" EG see Ba"Ch

In tavshil it's also assi le'achalufei, because all daysa is the same
dish, just with different ingredients, and if some daysa is allowed
people will allow all daysa.