[Avodah] Ein Mevatlin issur lechatchilah

[rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com]

This is a "redux" Re: Can we lechatchilah rely upon the b'di'avad whilst
under the auspices of an eino-Yehudi?

See SA O"Ch Hilchos YT
517:2

Regarding a Yisrael asking an eino-Yehudi to purshase something on YT.

Here is a key phrase that *MIGHT* have kashrus implications

SA.
> ...muttar... Aval im ragil b'chah assur.. D'EIN ZEH HASHUV B'DIAVAD
> KEIVAN D'RAGIL B'CHAH"

IOW what coulf be kosher b'diavad on an ocassional basis would fail if
done on a regular basis.

Illustration of how I'd apply it
If eino-Yehudi bakes dairy bread ONCE and labels the package only, I
can make a case that it slips through the g'zeira against baking dairy
bread w/o forming an intrinsic siman.

BUT
If I give hashgacha and the eino-Yehudi is ragil - then it's tantamount
to using a dairy bread l'chathcila w/o an intrinsic siman and l'chatchila
relying upon the package. [And that would depend upon where you stand
on that issue]

KT
RRW
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile