[Avodah] Seeing G'zeiros Everywhere 2

[rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com]

> 21 no kosher animal gelatin in USA [afaik acceptable in Israel and Europe]

> This example is particularly inappropriate. This is not any kind
> of gezera/takana. According to RMF and RAK it is completely assur and
> always has been, and the poskim who permit it are simply wrong. The USA
> agencies that forbid it are paskening like them. That's no different than
> ROY paskening like the Mechaber, or Temanim paskening like the Rambam.
> In Europe and EY they pasken otherwise.
> Zev Sero

Havvu m'sunnim baddin

There is not enough information yet to make that call IMHO so jumping
to conclusions will but hinder the process.
Consider this a jigsaw puzzle about 15% complete

If people wish to pontificate, fine! It's a free country. But if
one wants to learn a mishnah, then finish the mishnah before reaching
conclusions

Mussar Haskeil
Offlist I exclaimed that Mamrim 2:2 dealt with ANY bd not just BD hagadol

But I was wrong because I was too quick on the draw. In full context
my error was obvious

Zev has not sufficient data to say correct or wrong because the label
and taxonomy is nascent and not fully formed. It would be like saying
the Sun looks wrong during Day One when it was not finished until Day
Four. Only then may one judge tov or ra

KT
RRW
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile