[Avodah] Dishwashers 1
Isaac Balbin
Isaac.Balbin at rmit.edu.au
Tue Dec 15 16:58:46 PST 2009
> R' MB
>
> RnCL already expressed her belief that "bishul" here isn't really
> cooking, it's derekh bishul as defined by a shiur that was halakhah
> leMoshe miSinai.
Tangentially, there is an opinion (Shitas HoRashbo) where it can be extrapolated that for the purposes of Bishul after Bishul, microwave based cooking isn't considered bishul as it doesn't involve fire and so a potato kigel heated up the first time in this way may not be considered halachically d'orayso mevushal and one couldn't reheat it in a permitted way on shabbos. From what I recall the Rambam looks at the result, and the Rashbo needs it to be through fire for it to be bishul d'orayso. I could be wrong, of course :-)
> Thus, we're not supposed to be dealing with cooking,
> but with something defined ritually.
Yes. Bishul :-)
More information about the Avodah
mailing list