[Avodah] [Areivim] Halacha of speeding/Jewish ethicscurriculum de velopment help

rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com
Thu Oct 29 09:29:04 PDT 2009


> RRW rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com
> added the tangent:
>: Tangentially, what sefarim would be the bests text for teaching the
>: language of Poskim"?

> A historical survey of Shu"t.
> -Micha

Agreed! That would be along the lines of my own answer.

Here are a few supplements to the above

Beth Yosef and AhS who use methodology

Collections of Shu"T on the SA itself EG
1 Shaarei Teshuva, which is BH printed in the MB
2 corresponding Pischei Teshuva on YD etc.
3 the monumental and encyclopedic Darchei Teshuva on YD
-----------------

And if you want talmiddim learning Shas to think more Halachically
I recommend Rif-Rosh-Ran and maybe Mordechai, Yam shell Shlomoh etc.

+++++++++++++++

RE: heuristics, I kinda agree that human intelligence factors into the mix

What I advocate [at least] to be more objective is to make an algorithm of
what sources to research. IOW Create a hierarchy of authoritative sources

EG
For issur v'heter that might look like

Toras habbayis
Tur BY Darchei Moshe
SA-Rema shach + Taz

Must be seen first

For Hilchos Shabbos it might look like

Tur BY Darchei Moshe
SA-MB
Chayei Adam
Shemiras Shabbos kehilchessa

For Choshen Mishpat
Maybe
SA-Rema SMA Schach
Ketzos and or Nesivos

If a poseiq chooses his own set of heirarchy, let him declare it

EG A Sephardi might choose Rif-Rambam-BY-SA-Pri Chadash

KT
RRW
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile



More information about the Avodah mailing list