[Avodah] Hekker for Sukkah on Shmini Azteres

Stuart Feldhamer stuart.feldhamer at gmail.com
Mon Oct 12 12:57:26 PDT 2009


RAM:
> It seems that the idea of the omission of Layshev being a hekker
> contradicts the custom of saying the Yehi Ratzon on Shmini Atzeres. A
> chutznik should either say the Yehi Ratzon on Hashana Raba, or he
> should have a different reason for why the Layshev is omitted on Shmini
> Atzeres.

The Yehi Ratzon is l'maaseh, a tefilah you make upon leaving the Sukkah for
the last time that year. Regardless of the reason why, l'maaseh you are not
leaving the Sukkah until after Shmini Atzeret (if that is your minhag). It
would not make sense to say the Yehi Ratzon and then go back into the Succah
to have another meal.

Stuart




More information about the Avodah mailing list