[Avodah] Masneh al Mah Shekassav baTorah

[rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com]

MSS: 
> I think you have just answered your question. Their not making a tnai 
> against Torah -- and in fact they can't pasken against anything in 
> Torah. They are agreeing to be bound by particular people in cases 
> were they don't know what the din is...
...
> Good question: What happens when they paskened in a state of lack of 
> knowledge and then a TC comes to town? 

Maybe so 

Remember, though that the rules are not just about ignorance 

There are other rules 
EG two brothers 
A ger 
Etc. 

The torah says don't appoint these as dayyanim nevertheless by concent
they can be appointed despite their "P'sul"

And they are not just doing pesharah or arbitration! They have authority
to "subpeona" etc.

[I'm not saying there is NO answer, I'm just not clear what the answer
would be]

KT 
RRW 
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile