[Avodah] having a melech: lechatchila or bideved???
Harvey Benton
harvw613 at yahoo.com
Thu Oct 29 16:36:48 PDT 2009
Is having a melech a bidieved or a lechatchila?
In the torah it mentions "when you will ask for a king like the nations around you...." This sounds like to me that God does/did not want us to have a king like the rest of the nations, but, like the spies, and the shlav, God went along with it and instituted the mitzvah of us having a king.
This is also the view of the Rambam, if I am not mistaken, regarding the korbanos. It is only to appease us that Hashem instituted the korbanos as mitzvos, not necessarily because He wants us to have them....... HB
More information about the Avodah
mailing list