[Avodah] Sukkah on Shabbos

[rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com]

> This gezera is only for the rare individual who doesn't know what to
> do, and waits for the last minute to find out.

Broken record:

The gzeiro s in the mishnah as axiomatic

The GMARA assigns rabba's svara to it

The above puts the cart before the horse!

We don't have a svara in need of creating svaros! Adderabba the gzeira
is a given and the svara comes later. [Wolpoe's law #1 we know WHAT
but not always why]

Also certain g'zeiros are sui generis.

Nevertheless, It's still a pretty good question! But the shema yaavirena
is AFAIK never used to generate any gzeira. Rather it is Rabbah's svara
to explain the gzeiros that already [pre-]existed in the Mishnah! (Or
possibly from an old Sanhedrin)

it is possible that Mishnah Tosefta and even Yerushalmi did not know of
this dynamic.

Gutn Moed
RRW
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile