[Avodah] Thanksgiving

[rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com]

OK we have identified
Two opposing Poisitons

Chareidi: 
If society does it, it is or probably is "treif".

Liberal or M.O.
Thanksgiving is Kosher and let's embrace it.

Question:
How would R SR Hirsch have viewed it?  
Personally I'm guessing that his relationship with secular culture
was selective and that he would embrace anything inspiring, positive,
or uplifting as long there was no specific Halachic barrier.

I was wondering What do the "Hirschians" on Avodah think?

KT
RRW
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile