[Avodah] psak and rationality

[rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com]

> The CI is used by RHSchachter to permit the use of toledos hachamah
> for
> non-bishul <g> on Shabbos. It wasn't derekh bishul during the
> millennia
> of Torah, so it's not derekh bishul even in the days where a dud
> shemesh
> is common.»

I don't get it! I eman this thread!

Toldos hamma is assur gzreia atu toldos eish
Only hammah directly is muttar! Al pi rashi there is no need for gzeira
ayein sham.

Dud shemesh according to many posqim is toldas hama and assur
miderabbanan. That is because the hama heats an intermediary.

KT
RRW
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile