[Avodah] Women Learning Torah
rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com
rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com
Tue Aug 11 15:57:44 PDT 2009
Apparently some of my positions have been misperceived a bit.
I am taking a centrist 2-track approach (similar to Hirsch's 2-tiered
approach re: the hinuch for Yaakov and Esav)
Tier 1 women learn traditonally as before.
No gmara. Women learn basic Halachah etc. Kitzur SA, a smattering of
Midrash, mussar, etcm
Tier 2 Women are enabled - but not coerced - to learn what men learn.
Thus I support allowing women to choose a Hareidi-style education
OR
A RYDS-style fully modern yeshivisher curriculum, gmara and all.
And that no woman would be "shamed" into either role, rather to learn what best works for her as an individual.
No coercion
No one-size-fits-all
Freedom of their own destiny
No disabilities
The decision to produce Orthodox women clergy will be postponed; but
there will be women ready to go at any time.
It's about not forcing the issue, but allowing the issue.
It's about Liberty within the confines of Torah
------------------------
Q: Is it about concensus?
A: Not quite. I envision a range of options with individual communities
implementing it differently.
Q: Do you see Orthodox women being called "rabbi"?
A: maybe, maybe not.
Q: What about "tzenius"
A. Ideally I see women as leaders for women, and men as leaders for men.
Sort of like Moshe and Miryam at Yam Suf - "separate but equal"
EG We already have women teaching shabbos afternoon groups for women
in Teaneck. Works for me
Q: What about women teaching men?
A: Good question. I don't have all the parameters - but certainly
publications would work. Think Nechama Leibowitz.
KT
RRW
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile
More information about the Avodah
mailing list