[Avodah] Shmoneh esrei - 18/19
SBA
sba at sba2.com
Thu Mar 12 06:55:59 PDT 2009
From: D&E-H Bannett
SBA (OLD) ... hakdomo of the sefer Al HaGeulah ve'al HaTemurah ...quotes
the Bach (OCh 118) who "...shehis'chil bevinyan Yerushalayim vesayem
beChisei Dovid - she'ein hap'sicha me'ein hachasima..."
The AHVH goes on "...vetamtsis devarav - deshapir haveh chasima me'ein
hap'sicha deBinyan yerushalayim veChisei Dovid chada milsa....she'ein anu
mevakshin al binyan yerushalayim - ela be'ofen sheyihye raui leKisei Dovid
- lo be'ofen achar.."
....
But this is only a teirutz after the fact.
===============
I don't think so.
AIUI the Bach says [and the AHVH emphasizes] that the request for Boneh
Yerushalyaim must be with the vechisei Dovid.
>>>The AHVH doesnt even consider the possibility that there was only one
b'rakha in E"Y and, after they were separated, for some reason a piece of
one got stuck in the other.
I would suggest that the Nusach EY is even a stronger proof to the
abovementioned statement of the Bach
SBA
More information about the Avodah
mailing list