[Avodah] Ein Mevatlin issur lechatchilah

[rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com]

> Given A Jew may not mevateil issur lechatchilah
> And a corollary
> A Jew may not ask a Gentile to mevateil issur on his behalf.

RRW note:
Well technicallly you can ask a Gentile to do it but the product would
be assur see SA Yd 99:5 vkChen lemi shenisbatel bishvilo
See ba'eir hetev 10

Eli
> RMF has a teshuva allowing ice cream even though it contains small
> amounts of Gelatin which might be davar hamamid.

> Thus, it was obvious to RMF that once it is batel by the company
> one can buy it lechatchila and give a hechsher,

> BTW why are you so sure you can't ask a goy to be mevatel. Amira
> le-nochri is a halacha in shabbat not necessarily in all halachot

See note above

Reductio ad absurdum:

If Eli is correct then
In the case of had bitrei

Let Gentile mix up 1 neveilah with 2 kesheira pieces lechatchila.
Guard him from bringning in extra meat from outside and you can make a
ta'aroves with bittul lechatchila.

Good Purim
RRW
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile