[Avodah] Shmoneh esrei - 18/19

[SBA]

From: D&E-H Bannett 
Re:  <<I once heard (I know, this is usually not a good 
introduction to a reliable source) that Kallir purposely omitted a q'rova
for 
the bracha of "Et tzemach David" on Purim.
That's what the commentary in the Artscroll siddur states>>

I was not very surprised that Artscroll backs such 
teirutzim. What is the halakhic or other justification for 
ignoring the evidence of the Yerushalmi, the nusach of the 
combined b'rakha in the nusach E"Y found in the geniza and 
the lack of a krova for the extra b'rakha.
>>

I think you are being a bit harsh on Reb Art.

What they probably meant was as I saw in another publication on Yotzros etc
that there is much proof that RE Hakalir generally held with the Yerushalmi
v. Bavli. 
And so he id here re Kroyvetz.

SBA