[Avodah] hutra vs dechuya

[Shlomo Pick]

>I am giving a shiur on whether shabbat/pikuach nefesh is hutra or dechuya

 

>does anyone know a source that discusses in general hutra vs dechuya and
examples of hutra most aseh docheh lo taaseh seem to be dechuya

 

Nice that you said "seem to be".  Each case must be dealt independently.
Pikuach nefesh on shabbos is generally accepted to be dechuya, but that's
the rambam's opinion and has been accepted as halakha. However, Maharam
meRothenburg held it to be hutra!  I expect that's the topic of your shiur.

Pesach haba'a betuma is accepted as being hutra, but there is an opinion in
pesahim, that it is dechuya.

Similarly, I believe that shabbos in the mikdash is the same problem.

shlomo

 

 

 

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.aishdas.org/pipermail/avodah-aishdas.org/attachments/20090224/e0c89067/attachment-0001.htm>