[Avodah] Akeidah vs. Chet Eigel

[rabbirichwolpoe at gmail.com]

> Mah beinaihu? Are you saying that onesh is retribution as opposed to
> after-effect? If so, I disagree.
> -Micha

Lemashal
An arab steals his punishment is to lose his hand

The suffering he has afterwards is real but it's not the punishment.
One arab might live a few days another many years.

Adam harishon's punishment incuded a curse and galus from gan eden.
Even binyamin kil'av etc. Had to die w/o sin because of original sin's
legacy. So then HKBH according to you is always pokeid avon after 4
generations until the end of time.

According to me the punishment can spread over 4 doros but the impact
can be permanent.

We stll have no BhMikdash.  Punishment? Impact? Legacy? Pekidah?

KT
RRW
Sent via BlackBerry from T-Mobile