[Avodah] derabban and deoraisa

[Eli Turkel]

R' Joel Rich wrote:
> Now, what happens if Rabbi X says kosher and Y says treif &
> followers of each eat from the same pot - I suppose the effect
> (here and bashamayim) is different even though the molecules
> are the same.

Akiva Miller
I would that that this applies only if both were Real Rabbis, that is
to say, with Real Semicha -- which we do not have today.

Today, they would both be affected the same way, though were can't be
certain whether it was Rabbi X or Rabbi Y who was correct.>>

Real Semicha makes a difference for a bet din, malkot or monetary
fines why should it make a difference for Yoreh Deah type questions?


-- 
Eli Turkel