[Avodah] Sheva Brochos
SBA
sba at sba2.com
Tue Apr 8 00:41:06 PDT 2008
From: SBA [mailto:sba at sba2.com]
....I noticed that the Pischei Teshuva EH 62:9 writes beshem the Nodah
Beyehuda "..be'inyan noef shenoso be'uloso ein mevorchin sheva brochos ele
yom echad.."- as his Simcha is far less that in case of a bachur ubesula.
So BTs who after living together (in their previous life) and now get
married. If one makes 7Bs for a week is it a brocho levatolo?
>>
So I didn't look at the rest of that Pischei Teshuvah when I posted the
above.
Now that I did, I see that he quotes the CS as disagreeing with the NB on
this matter and seems to OK 7Bs for the whole week.
But the introduction of this CS (which comes from his Teshuvos - EH 123) is
very interesting.
He writes (regarding the marriage of a couple who had had pre-marital
relations):
"...ani omer - ma'us yimasu hanoef vehano'ofes, ve'einom rauim librocho,
ve'eich yekablu peneihem panim chadoshos kol shiva - veheimah bo'alei
niddos, choteh bal yisnoeh ubal yisgoeh... Ach, im yimtze'ui raim (re'im ?)
kemosom - lechadesh panim kol shiva - yevorchu lohem kol shiva..."
Is the CS saying that the only people who should be saying the sheva brochos
for these 'bo'alei niddos' are others who have similarly misbehaved?
SBA
More information about the Avodah
mailing list