[Avodah] Borchu UVoruch Shemo between Borchu and Shmono Esreh

Jonathan Baker jjbaker at panix.com
Mon Nov 26 07:19:36 PST 2007


RJR:
>Rmi:
>> I do not know why RYBS recommended saying the berakhah with the Chazan,
>> to avoid having to think about not wanting to be yotzei a mitzvah. Why
>> didn't he simply suggest answering BHUBS, and thereby not be yotzei?
 
> Iiuc he didn't answer bhbs to any brachot(minhag hagra?)

According to R' Bezalel Naor, the Gra opposed saying "BHUBS" because
missing the vav of "uvaruch" made the gematria of the phrase 814,
which is Shabtai Tzvi.  So he found ways to avoid saying it.  Perhaps
the Briskers (and RYBS) picked up on this aversion to BHUBS, even if
the original reason had since gone away?

And what is the significance of just saying "br'shmo", which seems to
be the most commmon way BHUBS is actually pronounced?

    Jonathan Baker      |  I have a little dreidel, I made with some gluons
    jjbaker at panix.com   |  When it's dry and ready, it'll spin like muons.
                    Blog: http://thanbook.blogspot.com/




More information about the Avodah mailing list