[Avodah] Alleged story about the SM"A

[SBA]

From: "Kelmar, Michael J." < >
Rabbi Richard Wolpe wrote: "Since the Sma was dead 7 years before the Shach
was born it would take someone from the extreme NON-HISTORICAL school to buy
into the above story!"

Clearly, the SM"A could have taken on the shita that later would become
known as the Shach's shita, even before the Shach's birth.
>>

The source for this story which I posted:
>>Shu"t Ksav Sofer YD: 109 - where the KS writes that he heard this "Mipeh
Kadosh Abba...ZT"L, ie the Chasam Sofer<<
doesn't mention any Shach.

SBA